- Academy of Mount St. Ursula (Bronx, NY)
- Albertus Magnus High School (Bardonia, NY)
- All Hallows High School (Bronx, NY)
- Archbishop Stepinac High School (White Plains, NY)
- Cardinal Hayes High School (Bronx, NY)
- Cardinal Spellman High School (Bronx, NY)
- Cathedral High School (New York, NY)
- Dominican Academy (New York, NY)
- Fordham Preparatory School (Bronx, NY)
- Iona Preparatory School (New Rochelle, NY)
- John S. Burke Catholic High School (Goshen, NY)
- Kennedy Catholic High School (Somers, NY)
- LaSalle Academy (New York, NY)
- Maria Regina High School (Hartsdale, NY)
- Monsignor Farrell High School (Staten Island, NY)
- Moore Catholic High School (Staten Island, NY)
- Mount St. Michael Academy (Bronx, NY)
- Msgr. Scanlan High School (Bronx, NY)
- Notre Dame Academy High School (Staten Island, NY)
- Notre Dame School of Manhattan (New York, NY)
- Our Lady of Lourdes High School (Poughkeepsie, NY)
- Preston High School (Bronx, NY)
- Sacred Heart High School (Yonkers, NY)
- Salesian High School (New Rochelle, NY)
- School of the Holy Child High School (Rye, NY)
- St. Catharine Academy (Bronx, NY)
- St. George Academy (New York, NY)
- St. Jean Baptiste High School (New York, NY)
- St. Joseph by the Sea High School (Staten Island, NY)
- St. Joseph Hill Academy High School (Staten Island, NY)
- St. Peter’s Boys High School (Staten Island, NY)
- St. Raymond Academy for Girls (Bronx, NY)
- St. Raymond High School for Boys (Bronx, NY)
- St. Vincent Ferrer High School (New York, NY)
- The Montfort Academy (Mount Vernon, NY)
- The Ursuline High School (New Rochelle, NY)
- Xavier High School (New York, NY)
